Gladiator II Stuns Critics: A Modern Epic Blends Nostalgia with Bold New Vision
The entertainment world is buzzing with reactions to Gladiator II, the long-awaited sequel to the 2000 Oscar-winning classic. As your entertainment correspondent, I’m here to break down the critical response to this massive undertaking that’s making waves across Hollywood.
Paul Mescal assumes the role of Lucius, the hidden offspring of Russell Crowe’s renowned Maximus in this franchise. At 28, Mescal brings a fresh energy to the arena, though he’s noticeably younger than Crowe’s 36 years when he first donned the gladiator’s armor. Critics have been quick to note his “stocky, swarthy, brooding presence” that commands attention on screen.
The sequel’s grand vision comes from legendary director Ridley Scott, who, at 86, shows no signs of slowing down. In fact, many critics suggest he’s becoming more daring with age. The Guardian’s Peter Bradshaw hails the film as a “thrilling spectacle” and “gobsmacking reboot,” while The FT celebrates Scott’s “stubborn charm” and “belligerent swagger.”
A standout element drawing universal praise is the film’s stunning visual effects. Unlike many modern blockbusters, the Colosseum wasn’t just created digitally; it was built as a massive physical set with real crowds. This commitment to practical effects adds a weight and authenticity that critics say you can feel in every frame.
Critics laud Denzel Washington for his portrayal of Macrinus, a Machiavellian former slave transformed into a gladiator manager. The Hollywood Reporter calls his performance “lip-smacking,” while The Times suggests the film “only ignites when Denzel Washington’s brilliant, bisexual slave manager is on screen.”
However, not all critics are raising their thumbs in approval. Some point out that the sequel falls into familiar territory—perhaps too familiar. The Telegraph’s Robbie Collin notes that while it’s “the year’s most relentlessly entertaining blockbuster,” it doesn’t quite match its predecessor’s impact. Kevin Maher at The Times takes a harder stance, calling it a “dreary, Marvel-esque sequel” in his two-star review.
The action sequences have gotten bigger and bolder, thanks to advances in technology. Viewers can expect to see gladiators riding charging rhinoceros and dramatic naval battles staged in a flooded Colosseum. These spectacular set pieces showcase Scott’s continued ability to push boundaries in action filmmaking.
One notable addition to the cast is the dual threat of Joseph Quinn and Fred Hechinger as Roman Emperor twins, who critics say bring a “distinct whiff of the ultimate mad emperor Caligula” to their roles. Critics have compared their performances favorably to Joaquin Phoenix’s memorable turn as Commodus in the original.
The film’s dramatic weight comes from its exploration of family ties and political intrigue. Connie Nielsen returns as Lucilla, bringing depth to a complex character whose relationships with both the original Maximus and his son Lucius add layers of emotional complexity to the story.
While some critics worry the sequel might not have the staying power of its predecessor—the FT is betting it won’t be “remembered by Christmas”—others see it as a worthy addition to the Gladiator legacy.
The Independent’s four-star review praises Scott’s willingness to take risks, noting that the film is “equal in scale and spectacle” to the original while adding its own unique flavor.
As the arena settles, one thing becomes clear: Gladiator II delivers what modern audiences crave—spectacular action, compelling performances, and enough ties to the original to satisfy longtime fans while forging its own path forward.
Are you not entertained? Most critics predict that you will be entertained.