Presumed Innocent Season 2: Here’s What’s Coming
Apple TV+ didn’t waste time. Just a month after Season 1 hit the screen, they gave Presumed Innocent Season 2 the green light. And no surprise there—the show took off fast, becoming one of Apple TV+’s top dramas.
Season 1 told the intense story of Rusty Sabich, a prosecutor accused of killing his former lover. The twist ending? Unexpected.
But Season 2? It’s changing everything. New case. New characters. New book. Instead of following Scott Turow’s novel again, the following season pulls from a fresh story by author Jo Murray. That means fans can expect a whole new kind of courtroom chaos.
Here’s the full scoop—what’s changing, what’s staying, and when we might see it.
When’s It Coming? Let’s Talk Dates
The second season quickly received the official go-ahead. Apple TV+ saw how big Season 1 was and knew fans wanted more.
So, when does it drop? While no exact date has been shared, most signs point to spring 2026. That’s when Jo Murray’s new book, Dissection of a Murder, is supposed to be released—and it’s the basis for Season 2. So the timing makes sense.
Once the book is out, production will likely follow. That gives the team time to cast new actors, write great scripts, and prepare everything for a solid release.
In short, nothing is official yet, but spring 2026 looks like the window to watch.
Who’s In—and Who’s Not—This Time?
Let’s talk cast. One big change? Jake Gyllenhaal is still involved—but maybe just behind the scenes. He’s returning as executive producer, but it’s not confirmed if he’ll act in Season 2. He might pop up in a small role. Or maybe not.
Peter Sarsgaard? He’s out. He played the prosecutor, Tommy Molto, in Season 1 but confirmed that his part was a one-season deal.
What about others like Ruth Negga or Bill Camp? No word yet. Since the new story doesn’t follow Rusty Sabich’s case, none of the original cast may return. The show might follow an anthology format, where each season has a new set of characters.
That leaves room for fresh talent. New roles. New tension. And maybe a few surprises.
| Actor | Role | Status | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jake Gyllenhaal | Unknown (possibly cameo) | Executive Producer | Not confirmed to appear on screen |
| New Lead Actress (TBA) | Leila Reynolds (Defense Attorney) | To Be Announced | The main character in a new case |
| New Actor (TBA) | Prosecutor / Leila’s Husband | To Be Announced | Leila’s husband, handling the same case |
| Peter Sarsgaard | Tommy Molto | Not Returning | Confirmed not returning |
| Ruth Negga | Barbara Sabich | Unconfirmed | May not return due to new storyline |
| Bill Camp | Raymond Horgan | Unconfirmed | Unlikely to return |
| Renate Reinsve | Carolyn Polhemus | Unconfirmed | The character arc ended in Season 1 |
What’s the New Story About?
Season 2 departs from the original novel and takes a bold new direction. The show will now be based on Jo Murray’s upcoming book, Dissection of a Murder.
The lead character is Leila Reynolds, a defense lawyer. She’s handling her first murder trial. Big case, big nerves. But there’s a twist—her husband is the prosecutor. Yup, the couple is going head-to-head in court. You can imagine how messy that gets.
Expect plenty of drama. Inside the courtroom. And outside of it.
The story brings fresh energy but keeps the dark, gripping tone fans loved in Season 1. Think high-pressure arguments, surprise twists, and moments that leave you on edge.
Since this case is new, nobody knows how it will end. That mystery makes the wait even more exciting.
Is There a Trailer Yet?
Not yet. And that’s normal.
Filming hasn’t started, so there’s nothing to show for now. But if the release is in spring 2026, fans can expect the first trailer to drop early that year, maybe late winter.
Looking back, Season 1’s trailer came just before the premiere. Apple TV+ will likely follow the same plan: a short teaser will be followed by full trailers, cast interviews, and social media sneak peeks.
Expect the marketing to focus on:
- The courtroom showdown between husband and wife
- A murder mystery that keeps you guessing
- Strong, emotional performances
The promo strategy will probably lean into the idea that you don’t need to see Season 1 to enjoy Season 2. That’s great for new viewers.
Quick Recap of What We Know (And What’s Still Missing)
Here’s a simple breakdown:
Season 2 has been confirmed, with Jake Gyllenhaal as one of the producers. No official release date or trailer is available, and the cast list remains undisclosed. This season is based on a new book, “Dissection of a Murder,” and viewers can expect an entirely new story featuring new characters.
So if you were hoping for answers… well, we’ve got a few. But much more will drop once filming starts and the promos begin rolling out.
Presumed Innocent Season 2 – Episode Guide
| Episode Number | Title (Placeholder) | Air Date | Summary (Speculative) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Episode 1 | “Opening Statements” | Spring 2026 | Leila Reynolds takes on her first murder case |
| Episode 2 | “Conflicts of Interest” | TBA | Leila realizes her husband is the prosecutor |
| Episode 3 | “Under Oath” | TBA | A key witness changes the direction of the case |
| Episode 4 | “The Breakdown” | TBA | Personal tensions affect Leila’s courtroom focus |
| Episode 5 | “Discovery” | TBA | A new piece of evidence surfaces with significant implications |
| Episode 6 | “Crossfire” | TBA | Trial proceedings grow more intense as the couple clash |
| Episode 7 | “Closing Arguments” | TBA | Both sides present their final case |
| Episode 8 | “The Verdict” | TBA | The jury reaches a decision—one that shocks everyone |
Note: These are placeholder titles and summaries. Apple TV+ will release the official episode list, which will be updated.
FAQs About Presumed Innocent Season 2
When is Season 2 coming out?
It looks like spring 2026, but nothing is set in stone yet.
Is Jake Gyllenhaal returning as an actor?
He’s still producing the show. It’s unclear if he’ll appear on screen again.
Is Peter Sarsgaard coming back?
Nope. He already confirmed he’s done after Season 1.
What’s the new season about?
Season 2 will follow Leila Reynolds, a defense lawyer in her first murder trial, based on Dissection of a Murder.
Does Season 2 connect to Season 1?
No. It’s a brand-new story with different characters and a different case.
Is there a trailer yet?
Not yet. Expect one a few weeks before the release date.
Final Thoughts
Presumed Innocent Season 2 is taking a bold step away from the original book and going all-in on something new. A new case. New faces. And a courtroom battle with a husband and wife on opposite sides.
While some fan-favorite actors won’t return, the show’s new direction opens up endless possibilities. The switch to Jo Murray’s book gives the series room to grow—and keeps things fresh for viewers.
No trailer. No cast list. But fans are already buzzing. So hang tight. Spring 2026 isn’t that far away. When updates drop, we’ll be watching.