Can an Attorney Negotiate a Probation Violation

Probation is a great way for offenses to be handled in the criminal justice system. It allows people who have committed certain offenses to stay out of prison and put their lives back together by adhering to certain conditions imposed by a judge. Not all cases will involve full probation but instead may include early release or leniency otherwise granted by an appellate court or prosecutor.

However, when convicted of a crime, probationers are expected to report any violations they may have in order to remain out of jail. An attorney can negotiate a favorable probation violation settlement that may help keep your client from jail and comply with the terms of their sentence without facing additional criminal charges.

This article will provide an overview of how an attorney can help navigate the process of negotiating probation violations and the complexities that may be encountered along the way.

What is a Probation Violation?

A probation violation is an intentional or negligent action that breaks the specific terms and conditions set forth in a defendant’s probation agreement. Common examples of violations include: failing to report to a probation officer, failing to complete court-ordered programs or classes, getting arrested for another crime, and possessing or using drugs. As soon as any violations occur, the probationer should contact their attorney immediately.

When a judge finds an individual guilty of committing a violation of their probation, they have the authority to modify or revoke the original sentence and impose punishments such as fines, additional imprisonment time, restitution payments, or further supervised release periods with strict conditions attached. The exact outcomes vary greatly depending on the severity of the violation and the existence of prior offenses.

Suppose an individual believes they have been wrongly accused of violating their probation agreement due to accidental interference by third parties, such as changes in employment or unforeseen relocations outside of where they are allowed to travel with permission from their probation supervisor. In that case, it is possible for an experienced criminal defense attorney familiar with local laws related to probation violations to represent them during hearings in which pleas may be entered for leniency on behalf of their client.

Additionally, attorneys may be able to negotiate alternative sentencing in lieu of more severe punishment if possible within reason based upon existing evidence presented during court proceedings regarding committed offenses.

Generally speaking though, it is important for those who are placed on probation for any reason whatsoever to remain vigilant about fulfilling all requirements set forth and keep tenacious documentation around any circumstances that led to any potential contact with officers involved in supervision–in order to ensure more responsible outcomes when negotiating potential violation matters with prosecutors.

What Can an Attorney Do to Help?

A lawyer can be a critical asset if you’re accused of a probation violation. An experienced attorney will be able to review your case, investigate the facts, and negotiate on your behalf with the court and/or the prosecuting attorney.

An attorney can also identify any potential defenses that may be available to you and the arguments that can be made in your favor. In addition, an attorney can help guide you through the legal process and make sure that your rights are protected.

Negotiate a Reduced Penalty

Criminal defense attorneys can be invaluable assets for those facing probation violations. A lawyer can help to assess the case and determine the best options for resolving the violation without a jail sentence or without getting one’s probation revoked.

If a probation violation is awaiting formal sentencing, an attorney may be able to negotiate a reduced penalty with the court. This may involve reaching a plea agreement, in which the defendant agrees to plead guilty to a particular charge in exchange for more lenient sentencing than what would have been expected otherwise.

An experienced attorney will also be able to evaluate all legal options and determine if there are grounds for dismissal of the violation prior to adjudication. If this is possible, it may save months or years of unwelcome repercussions if convicted of violating one’s probation terms.

In some cases, requests can be made on behalf of clients wherein they begin rehabilitation programs or participate in treatment sessions in lieu of conventional punishment if found guilty of violating their probation term. Here too an attorney can provide valuable assistance that is critical in negotiating with prosecutors and judges.

Request Early Termination of Probation

If a person on probation has shown that they can adhere to all the conditions of the probation, an attorney may be able to negotiate for early termination with the prosecuting attorney and judge. Before early termination can be requested, however, certain conditions must first be fulfilled.

The duration and specifics of these requirements will depend on the jurisdiction where a person is on probation and their individual charges. For example, some courts may require that all fines have been paid in full or that all court-ordered classes have been successfully completed.

Additionally, many jurisdictions require a waiting period before an early termination request can even be submitted. It is crucial to note that early termination requests can only be submitted by those on probation who have committed no further crimes or violations during their supervision period.

Therefore, if a person has been charged with an additional offense while they are being monitored under probation rules, they may not be eligible for early termination of their sentence.

Additionally, it is also important to consider whether or not an individual’s criminal history could lead prosecutors or judges to deny their request regardless of whether they meet the requirements for good behavior while on probation.

An experienced attorney will understand the standards imposed in a given jurisdiction and can assess whether these conditions have been fulfilled by those seeking early termination. With the appropriate evidence offered by legal counsel and appropriate smoothing done by an attorney make sure they are making the best possible case for their client’s request for early release from probationary conditions.

What Factors Will a Court Consider?

If you have violated the terms of your probation, you may have the opportunity to have an attorney negotiate on your behalf to have your probation reinstated.

However, it is important to understand that there are certain factors the court may take into consideration when determining the outcome. These factors will be discussed in the upcoming paragraphs.

The Nature of the Violation

The court will examine the circumstances and the nature of the probation violation when deciding whether or not to accept a plea bargain negotiated by an attorney. Judges and prosecutors will likely want to know why the violation occurred and how it happened.

If the defendant can provide an acceptable explanation for the violation, it may help convince the court to be more lenient.

The court may also take into account any mitigating circumstances, such as if the defendant has served most of the original sentence; or if there were extenuating factors involved in causing the violation, such as an illness or other disability that made it difficult for them to comply with their probationary requirements.

Additionally, if there were aggravating circumstances – for example, if a weapon had been used in connection with a crime – then this could also lead to harsher repercussions.

Another factor that courts may consider is whether or not this is a first-time offense: they will usually be more willing to accept a plea bargain from someone who is not seen as being a habitual violator of probationary requirements.

Furthermore, courts typically give higher consideration to defendants who are deemed “low risk” – those who have demonstrated their willingness to comply with conditions set forth in their probation agreement and make efforts to transition back into society without causing any further problems or legal issues.

The Defendant’s Criminal History

When evaluating whether to negotiate a probation violation, a court will consider a number of factors, including the defendant’s criminal history and the severity of the violation itself. The court will look at any prior convictions, pending charges, and any probation or parole violations in order to determine how serious of an offender this individual is and whether they are likely to repeat their offense again.

Depending on these factors, the court may be willing to negotiate more lenient penalties such as reduced jail time or additional drug testing requirements instead of revoking their probation.

Additionally, if the crime committed can be relatively easily addressed through additional educational training or counseling sessions, those suggestions can sometimes be pushed for by the attorney in order to reduce or avoid harsher punishments.

The Defendant’s Compliance with Probation Terms

The court will consider how well the defendant has complied with the terms of their probation when deciding whether to modify or revoke it. The judge may take into account any previous violations, efforts to fulfill the conditions of probation, and evidence that the defendant has made progress toward rehabilitation.

If there is evidence that the defendant is cooperating with their probation officer and/or making attempts to rectify a situation stemming from a violation, they may be more likely to receive leniency from the court.

Furthermore, if a defendant can show that their current circumstances are different from those which led them to initially violate their probation, this may persuade the court to view things in a more favorable light.

A knowledgeable attorney can present arguments based on these factors or other mitigating circumstances in an effort to negotiate with prosecutors for reduced or alternative sentencing for violations of probation.


The decision to hire an attorney to negotiate a probation violation should not be taken lightly. While an attorney can often help, they can’t guarantee success. You should also keep in mind that negotiating a probation violation may involve additional financial considerations, both in terms of lawyer’s fees and court costs, depending on the jurisdiction.

However, with an experienced attorney on your side who knows the relevant laws and statutes associated with probation violations in your state, you can ensure that you receive the best available outcome for your particular situation.

An attorney can also provide critical advice about how best to proceed throughout all stages of the process, from the initial arrest to the final disposition. In some cases, this outside counsel may be crucial for helping you avoid further legal troubles and maintain an appropriate level of compliance during future periods of probation or parole.

Leave a Comment